Logo
Logo

NY Giants acquire QB J.J. McCarthy from Vikings, maintain Jameis Winston as QB1

The New York Giants have acquired quarterback J.J. McCarthy from the Minnesota Vikings in exchange for a 2027 fifth-round draft pick. Despite the trade, Giants head coach John Harbaugh confirmed that Jameis Winston will remain the team’s starting quarterback for the foreseeable future as McCarthy acclimates to the offense.

NY Giants acquire QB J.J. McCarthy from Vikings, maintain Jameis Winston as QB1
NY Giants acquire QB J.J. McCarthy from Vikings, maintain Jameis Winston as QB1.

Giants quarterback situation and trade details

  • Trade Terms: The Giants traded a 2027 fifth-round pick to Minnesota for McCarthy, who was selected No. 10 overall in the 2024 NFL Draft.
  • Winston Retains Starting Role: Winston remains QB1 following a season-ending knee injury to starter Jaxson Dart, who underwent surgery Friday to repair his meniscus and MCL. Since taking over, Winston has completed 51% of his passes for 229 yards, 0 touchdowns, and 1 interception.
  • Giants Roster Moves: The Giants waived quarterback Jake Haener from the active roster on Monday with plans to re-sign him to the practice squad once he clears waivers.
  • Team Context: The Giants improved to 2–1 following a 12–7 victory over the Tennessee Titans without scoring a touchdown. They host the Arizona Cardinals this Sunday.
  • Scouting Background: The Giants heavily scouted McCarthy out of Michigan—where he was coached by John Harbaugh’s brother, Jim Harbaugh—and considered drafting him with the sixth overall pick in 2024.

McCarthy’s departure from Minnesota

  • Demotion and Injury: McCarthy lost the Vikings’ starting job during training camp to Kyler Murray and was demoted to third-string behind Murray and Carson Wentz following an ankle sprain in an August 22 preseason game against Baltimore.
  • Vikings Tenure: At 23 years and 9 months old, McCarthy leaves Minnesota with 10 career starts. Vikings leadership cited a combination of injuries, poor throwing mechanics, and immaturity for moving on from the former first-rounder.
  • Executive & Coach Statements:
    • Vikings GM Nolan Teasley: Stated that receiving a draft asset made sense to help continue building a constantly evolving roster.
    • Vikings HC Kevin O’Connell: Expressed that while McCarthy developed and improved during his tenure, NFL teams do not have unlimited time to wait on young quarterback development.

Historical context & player comparison

CategoryStatistical / Historical Fact
Vikings 1st-Round OutliersAccording to Elias Sports Bureau, McCarthy is one of four Vikings first-round picks to play 10 or fewer games for the franchise, joining Lewis Cine, Dimitrius Underwood, and Leo Hayden.
NFL 25-Year RarityOver the last 25 years, McCarthy is one of only four quarterbacks to make 10 or fewer starts for the team that drafted them, alongside Paxton Lynch, Trey Lance, and Johnny Manziel (excluding the 2004 Eli Manning/Philip Rivers draft day trade).
Giants Current BackfieldMcCarthy enters the Giants’ QB room as the No. 2 or No. 3 option while learning the playbook, behind starter Jameis Winston.

Categories:

Most recent

Michael King steps up in relief as Padres defeat Brewers 4-3 to force game 4 of NLDS

Michael King steps up in relief as Padres defeat Brewers 4-3 to force game 4 of NLDS

San Diego Padres starter Michael King pitched two scoreless relief innings on short rest to secure a 4-3 victory over the Milwaukee Brewers in Game 3 of the National League Division Series at Petco Park. With key setup man Adrian Morejon injured and star closer Mason Miller placed on the paternity list shortly before first pitch, King volunteered out of the bullpen to preserve the win and keep San Diego's season alive.

Luka Doncic scores 21 as Lakers debut high-press defense in preseason victory over Kings

Luka Doncic scores 21 as Lakers debut high-press defense in preseason victory over Kings

The Los Angeles Lakers unveiled an aggressive, high-pressure defensive scheme in a 127-103 preseason win over the Sacramento Kings on Monday at Golden 1 Center. Led by 21 points from Luka Doncic, the Lakers swarmed the Kings from the opening tip, building a 26-point halftime cushion behind perimeter pressure and active wing play.

Tom Brady addresses on-air audio glitch during Eagles-Rams broadcast

Tom Brady addresses on-air audio glitch during Eagles-Rams broadcast

Seven-time Super Bowl champion Tom Brady briefly went silent during Sunday’s FOX Sports broadcast of the Philadelphia Eagles vs. Los Angeles Rams game before revealing that an accidental button press caused the audio malfunction. The former quarterback took full responsibility for the awkward moment on-air, turning the mishap into a lighthearted exchange with broadcast partner Kevin Burkhardt.

Long’s Bakery Transforms for Launch of Caitlin Clark’s Signature Nike Caitlin 1 Shoe

Long’s Bakery Transforms for Launch of Caitlin Clark’s Signature Nike Caitlin 1 Shoe

Long's Bakery on the west side of Indianapolis has transformed into "Caitlin's Extraordinary Treats" to celebrate the worldwide release of Indiana Fever star Caitlin Clark's inaugural signature sneaker, the Nike "Caitlin 1," on Thursday, October 1.

D’Angelo Russell signs with CBA’s Shanghai Sharks following Grizzlies release

D’Angelo Russell signs with CBA’s Shanghai Sharks following Grizzlies release

Former All-Star guard D'Angelo Russell is signing with the Shanghai Sharks for the upcoming Chinese Basketball Association (CBA) season following his release from the Memphis Grizzlies, the CBA announced Wednesday.

Washington Commanders expected to sign free-agent RB Austin Ekeler

Washington Commanders expected to sign free-agent RB Austin Ekeler

The Washington Commanders are expected to sign free-agent running back Austin Ekeler to their 53-man roster, pending a physical, according to reports from NFL Network Insiders Ian Rapoport and Mike Garafolo.